The BMJ: Training Idlib’s obstetricians
Giving birth is one of the most vulnerable moments a woman can experience. It can be anxiety-inducing enough in a well-equipped hospital in the UK, but the women of Idlib, Syria are literally having their babies in a warzone. The threats they face are myriad, not only to themselves and their babies, but also to the physical fabric of the hospital and the medical workers who care for them. In early September the Has hospital was barrel-bombed and put out of action. Ambulance stations and a Syria Civil Defence (White Helmets) first response centre were also put out of service.
Beneath the headlines about “shapeshifting” rebel groups which have formed, fractured, and re-formed over the course of the civil war, and deals cut in regional capitals, is the suffering of the civilian population of Idlib, the last province in Syria not under regime control.
The numbers are stark; 336 maternal deaths per 100,000 births in provinces outside government control in Syria. [1] There are 9 per 100,000 in the UK. The figures for neonatal deaths are similarly distressing; 30.6 deaths per 1,000 births in Idlib compared to 3/1,000 in the UK. [2]
Violence against hospitals and medical staff affects clinical decision-making.
On 19 March 2018, the Union of Medical Care and Relief Organisations (UOSSM) reported that doctors in eastern Ghouta had, on the previous day, performed 15 caesarean sections out of a total of 30 births. The doctors said that they were being forced to do caesareans as the intense besiegement made it difficult for expecting mothers to predict when they could safely go to the hospital. The risk of complications for the mother and child are increased by the lack of incubators, medical equipment, and staff with the right training to perform follow up care.
However, the war alone cannot explain the high levels of maternal and neonatal morbidity. There is a serious shortage of obstetricians and midwives to care for a population of some 3 million. This can lead to non-specialists having to undertake the care of pregnant women and neonates and sometimes not making the correct decision for the patient. While not all of that population of 3 million will be having children, of course, the pressure on health services has increased as much of that population is made up of internally displaced people from areas including eastern Aleppo, eastern Ghouta and Homs. The province has become a receptacle for the vanquished as the regime has hammered those opposed to Assad’s rule. Following relentless campaigns of bombing and the use of chemical weapons, those civilians left alive boarded buses for Idlib province.
Among those on the green buses heading for Idlib in December 2016 was Farida; known as the last obstetrician in eastern Aleppo. Farida made impassioned pleas for the indiscriminate bombardment of her City to stop on several media channels in 2016. Her departure with her husband and daughter is an evident source of present pain, but there was something about those months leading up to the evacuation. “We made a difference. We were working so hard and helping so many people. Though we were under constant attack, we were part of something extraordinary and saving lives every day.”
Farida and 17 other obstetricians were in Gaziantep recently for Systematic Management and Emergency Care in Obstetrics and Midwifery (SMEC-OM), a course organised and funded by the David Nott Foundation, Hand in Hand for Aid and Development, and World Vision International. The Syrian civil war has stalled the medical education of doctors and midwives, a further major contributing factor to the poor outcomes in obstetrics and gynaecology. Postpartum haemorrhage and eclampsia/pre-eclampsia were responsible for the majority of maternal deaths in areas of Syria not under government control in 2017. [3] The SMEC-OM has been devised to save the lives of mothers and babies by training clinicians to use established algorithms and guidelines for managing conditions such as maternal collapse, post-partum haemorrhage, pre-eclampsia, sepsis, and neonate resuscitation. The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RCOG) in London is supporting these efforts and the course is conducted under the auspices of its Syrian Liaison Group.
Organising this essential training is Saladin Sawan, a British-Syrian gynaecologist. Saladin is joined by a faculty of trainers from several Arab states, all of whom give up their time for free. They lecture with authority and passion for their subject, inviting debate and questions from the doctors, 90% of whom are women. The energy in the room is palpable as they question graphs and diagrams and participate in practical exercises on specialist obstetric simulator models.
What they learn is being measured by an exam comprising both a paper of multiple-choice questions and a practical assessment on a simulator. The candidates who perform most strongly in the assessment proceed to a “train the trainers” day, where they will be coached to provide help and supervision to their colleagues in Idlib. This is especially important as 35 candidates had registered to attend the training but only 18 were able to make it across the Turkish border.
Getting the best in surgical training to those who need it most is the mission of the David Nott Foundation and we were proud to be able to support this thorough, detailed training.
In the coffee area I meet Abdulaziz. Before the war, Abdulaziz was a surgeon at Aleppo University Hospital and lecturer at the University’s faculty of medicine. With a small group of others, he was instrumental in locating safe houses where emergency operations could be performed on wounded protesters in the early days of the revolution. At night he gave lectures to medical students over Skype; focusing on emergency first aid and treating gunshot wounds. [4]
It is the focused effort of Abdulaziz, Saladin, and countless other individuals and charities that has created a shadow health system in areas of Syria not under government control. As the Syrian regime and its Russian supporters bombed hospitals and medical facilities, they scrambled to set up new ones underground and in caves. As the number of doctors shrank, they strove to train and upskill those who remained.
Idlib is the final front in the Syrian civil war and it is uncertain whether the current ceasefire will hold. The diplomats and politicians negotiating Syria’s fate owe it to the obstetricians I met in Gaziantep, and the thousands of women and babies who depend on them, to come up with a solution which creates the peace, security and dignity they so greatly deserve.
Elly Nott, Co-Founder and Chief Executive, David Nott Foundation
References:
1] 2017 survey conducted by the Syrian Board of Medical Specialities (SBOMS), “article in preparation”
2] World Bank data
3] 2017 survey conducted by the Syrian Board of Medical Specialities (SBOMS), “article in preparation”
4] Ben Taub, ‘The Shadow Doctors,’ The New Yorker, June 27, 2016 Issue
Originally posted on: https://blogs.bmj.com/bmj/2018/11/09/elly-nott-training-idlibs-obstetricians/
The Mail on Sunday: My secret mission to save Aleppo’s babies of the blitz
David Nott writes for The Mail on Sunday
Of all the wounded children of Aleppo who passed before me, the memory of one has lodged in my mind like no other. Maram. I spent the week before Christmas in a field hospital in Syria operating on many tiny souls see-sawing between life and death, their bodies held together with metal pins and scaffold-like fixators.
But in Maram, a five-month-old orphan and beautiful despite her injuries, I saw my own child and, perhaps because I missed her so desperately, I felt intensely overwhelmed.
I have made numerous trips to Syria to treat the casualties of this war, but none was as sorrowful as the week I spent with Aleppo’s children. Bone-weary and drained emotionally, I returned to London on Christmas Eve and couldn’t wait to hold my 17-month-old daughter and see my wife and family. Christmas was a joy.
Yet Maram was never far from my mind’s eye: a haunting, residual memory that I could not have shaken even if I had wished; I find myself waking in the early hours worrying about her. I first saw Maram on December 20, a few days after she was evacuated from Aleppo in an ambulance. Her legs and left arm had been shattered in a bomb attack that killed her parents and injured her brother and sister.
Pieces of ordnance shell were embedded in her infected wounds but, because the Aleppo doctors had run out of dressings, disinfectant and saline, they had no choice but to operate on her dirty body tissue. As I looked down at Maram on the treatment table she was crying, not because she was tired and hungry, even though she was both, but because she was in great pain.
There are no paediatricians in Aleppo, or at the hospital where I was working; nobody qualified to make the very difficult decisions about how much analgesics and fluids to dispense. So in spite of all her suffering, Maram was simply on a small dose of paracetamol. It was heartbreaking. I checked her charts. In the UK, these would have been filled in with scrupulous attention to detail, but in Syria, with doctors battling to save the lives of so many, charts were overlooked. I couldn’t even tell what medication she had already received.
Maram wriggled uncomfortably. I tried to think logically about how to help her and what I’d need to do when I operated on her the following day. But precise thought was difficult as I felt myself experiencing the same sort of emotions that any father would have towards a wounded child.
I operated on December 21, carefully debriding Maram’s wounds and removing the decaying tissue inside her. The whole hospital stank of the bacteria that had caused her infections, and those in other patients. I worked delicately around the open compound fracture Maram had suffered in her left leg.
Correctly in my opinion, the surgeon who had operated on her in Aleppo had applied an external fixator, but this was so big and heavy that Maram couldn’t move her leg when she was awake. It was so sad to see. She also had a pin in her femur and another in her tibia, and she had a really big gap of leg bone missing from the explosion.
Read more here.
The Observer: In Aleppo’s destroyed hospitals the dead lie with the living
David writes for The Observer
I don’t think that in all my years of doing this I’ve ever seen such dreadful pictures of injuries, of people lying on the floor of an emergency room, the dead mixed with the living.
One colleague, who I speak to all the time, was in despair, sending me all these photographs, and saying: “David, you have to do something to help us.” But what can I do?
The message out of eastern Aleppo is that there are no hospitals functioning at all. They have all been repeatedly attacked in the past few days. Some were able to evacuate, but one was totally and utterly destroyed by rockets and bombs. I heard that two doctors were killed and 16 other staff injured and I am afraid that one of the dead may be a brilliant surgeon, who would be a particularly serious loss.
There is another hospital that we haven’t even had a message from. So, I suspect they are out of action, but we know nothing about the staff or the conditions there.
The Aleppo hospitals have been re-opened so many times, underground or at new locations, but between the bombing and the siege I don’t know if it will be possible to resurrect them this time. There is so much equipment that you need in order to operate and there is no sterilisation and no monitoring machines for anaesthetics. Even if the hospitals saved some machines they can’t run them because the generators have been destroyed or are out of fuel.
The taking out of every hospital and medical facility that gives hope and help to civilians is not a coincidence. The medics have such fantastic morale that you would not imagine them giving up, but I have an awful suspicion that this is the endgame.
Read the full article here.
The Mail on Sunday: The abomination in Aleppo from Russian bomb.
David Nott for The Mail on Sunday
The text message from Aleppo flashed up on my phone as I was curled up on the sofa watching animated film The Good Dinosaur with my wife and 14-month-old daughter. It came from a much-loved Syrian friend, a surgeon like me.
Written in haste, it read starkly: ‘Massacres in Aleppo today… 168 cases arrived at the hospital. All of them civilians and mostly children.’
The scene of family contentment at my home in South-West London instantly dissolved. For the next 48 hours I dispensed advice, directed an operation and issued general instructions via instant messaging service WhatsApp to medics 2,500 miles away as they fought to save the lives of children pulverised by ball-bearings from cluster bombs dropped from the skies above the most benighted city on Earth.
Those injured had been lined up in an orderly queue at the time, waiting for bread to feed their starving families. As it transpired, 50 children were taken to hospital M10, the codename used by local doctors to disguise its location. Twenty were dead before they got there; others would succumb to their injuries.
Of the rest, no one knows for sure because over the next few days the hospital – which moved underground in 2014 – was repeatedly blasted from above, on at least one occasion by Russian bombs, until finally it was no more.
That Saturday evening, my colleagues in Aleppo sent me photos of many victims, not only so I would help but also in the hope I would alert the world. A world that isn’t listening and that has averted its gaze.
There were dust-covered dead children; mangled infants teetering between life and death; a little boy, one of the luckier souls, holding his smashed hand aloft; there were X-rays in which ball-bearings lodged in spines and brains appeared as little white spots.
Some of the images I couldn’t bear to open – there were just too many – and there are those I did open and that will never leave me. It was all so painful. Two brothers, for instance, aged about four and six, were pictured side by side on a trolley, life ebbing from them with each passing hour. Later I would learn they both died the following day because there were no fluids to give them and no ventilators available. No one knew their names.
Read the full article here.
The Times: Surgeons save Syrian lives by Skype
The messages arrive at all hours of the day and night, the vibration of a mobile phone signalling that another life hangs by a thread in Aleppo.
For the renowned British trauma surgeon David Nott and other doctors in London, Seattle, Washington and West Virginia, the Russian-backed onslaught on the city has been a daily reality.
They are a loose network of doctors who provide real-time medical support, often via WhatsApp and Skype internet services, to the desperately overstretched and sometimes dangerously inexperienced medical staff in the besieged areas of Syria.
Read the full story here.
BBC Newsnight: The doctors ‘breaking the siege’ in Aleppo via Skype
The battle over Aleppo has been raging for more than five years – with the Syria city under siege for much of this time.
The medical and humanitarian situation is desperate.
Two years ago, British doctor David Nott got into Aleppo to help train doctors there. Now he’s helping to get round the siege by directing life-saving operations via Skype. He spoke to BBC Newsnight.
Watch the full report here.
BBC Radio 4: ‘Aleppo doctors facing armageddon’
A British volunteer is worried for his colleagues as two hospitals in Aleppo, Syria, were hit during an aerial bombardment and are vulnerable to further attacks.
David Nott is a British surgeon and has worked in the hospitals and trained some of the doctors who treat people with the terrible injuries inflicted by these bombs.
He told World At One reporter Becky Milligan of his concerns for the doctors still working there and how he feels like a father to many.
More here.
David Nott Foundation concludes first surgical training course in Turkey
The first David Nott Foundation Hostile Environment Surgical Training (HEST) course concluded in Gaziantep, Turkey on 17 April, 2016. The HEST course is a satellite of the Surgical Training for the Austere Environment (STAE) course which David directs at the Royal College of Surgeons of England. The HEST course has a smaller faculty and fewer resource needs meaning it can take surgical training right to the front line.
Eight faculty members, including Course Director David Nott, taught 30 Syrian doctors life-saving surgical techniques. They were taught neurosurgery, maxillo-facial, thoracic, cardiac, abdominal, vascular and paediatric surgery, orthopaedics and obstetrics and gynaecology.
The Syrian doctors travelled from Hama, Homs, Idlib and Aleppo to be taught by David and his faculty. Many of the surgeons David had worked with before, during his visits to Syria in 2012, 2013 and 2014.
‘It was wonderful to see so many familiar faces and continue the teaching I have been honoured to be able to give over many years to my Syrian friends. By holding this course on the Turkish-Syrian border we are bringing life-saving surgical techniques directly to the people who need them most. Following the fantastic response to this inaugural course, we will in the future hold more HEST courses wherever in the world there is the need,’ David said.
David with the HEST faculty and students
The Telegraph: ‘They looked like they were coming out of a concentration camp’
By Raf Sanchez, Middle East Correspondent
For fifteen hours a day, the flow of wounded men, women and children from the remains of Syria’s largest city did not stop. Aleppo residents – evacuated to the safety of the countryside after a six-month siege – came with bones jutting through their skin, limbs succumbing to gangrene and shrapnel still buried in their wounds.
“They looked almost like they were coming out of a concentration camp,” said David Nott, a British surgeon who returned to Britain last week after spending eight days in Syria’s Idlib province treating the injured.
Dr Nott works in operating theatres across three London hospitals but has made repeated medical trips into Syria since fighting started in 2011. He trained many of the doctors who worked in east Aleppo’s makeshift hospitals throughout the regime siege and Russian bombardment and wanted to be there to help when 30,000 civilians and fighters finally left the city in early December under the terms of a ceasefire deal.
Over the course of a frenetic week of surgery, he operated on 90 people, including 30 children. “The patients were really in desperate state” after months with little food and harrowing journey out of the city through snow and freezing temperatures, Dr Nott said.
“They were coming in not just injured but dehydrated, malnourished, and psychologically traumatised.” Doctors in Aleppo focused on saving “lives not limbs” and performed hundreds of rapid amputations with only valium and ketamine to offer their patients for the pain. With no way of sterilising the wounds, the injuries became infected and Dr Nott and his colleagues were sometimes forced to amputate a second time in order to keep people alive.
Read more here.